Jeet Kune Do, Wing Chun, Trapping, Self Defense, & Bruce Lee
March 6th, 2009 · by Nhan-Esteban Khuong · Filed Under: Technique · bruce lee · self defense
Here is a question I was recently asked that points toward a very prevalent issue in the JKD world.
Question:
“Recently when I was training at my JKD school, one of my instructors told me that Wing Chun and trapping pretty much don’t have a place in street fighting. He says that he doesn’t teach it and Bruce Lee pretty much did away with Wing Chun and trapping as JKD evolved. I find that pill hard to swallow and wanted to get a second opinion. What is your take on what he says?”
Response:
This is a much debated topic in the JKD community. The root of the issue lies in that Bruce Lee did not leave explicit and definitive instructions on Jeet Kune Do.
The fact of the matter is that Bruce Lee’s fighting method was evolving and he taught various aspects of his developing skills to different people at different times of his personal progression.
In most cases he was probably not focusing on teaching, but rather testing, developing, and evolving ideas.
To say that he did away with trapping and Wing Chun is ludicrous because one cannot simply throw away something that is a part of you. It would be more appropriate to say that he de-emphasized, simplified, or simply modified it to a degree that it no longer appeared to be what he was originally doing.
It’s true that in the later stages of Jeet Kune Do, Bruce Lee seemed to be focusing his efforts on ideas inspired by fencing as opposed to Wing Chun. Concepts revolving around efficiency, interception and deceptive entry seemed to take precedence over the complex and often passive maneuvers in typical compound trapping.
Furthermore, the material that Bruce Lee was teaching or experimenting with was not necessarily the extent of what he was personally practicing. For example, although he was no longer teaching many of the Wing Chun techniques, he was known to have still practiced the Wing Chun wooden dummy forms.
As a teacher and martial artist myself I can relate because my own approach is also constantly evolving. I began with Tang Soo Do 25 years ago, and although I no longer use most of the techniques and approaches, there are fundamental skills that have proven valuable to me with much positive carryover into my JKD. As such, I do incorporate some simplified and highly modified training elements into my teaching methodology. The same goes with my background in boxing, grappling, and everything else that is a part of me.
In any case, Bruce Lee died before I was born, so all of my information is second hand at best. The reality is that no one really knows what Bruce Lee was thinking. We can only extrapolate based on his writings, films, family, friends, and his first generation students, very few of whom seem to really agree with one another. Go figure!
As for the effectiveness of Wing Chun and trapping in street fighting, I’ll say this: anything has the potential to work given enough of the right kind of training. The real issue in commercial martial arts is: what works most effectively for the average person who is unwilling to put the time and energy into REAL skill development.
In Health,
-
Nhan-Esteban Khuong, L.Ac.
Jeet Kune Do Los Angeles
















