The human body is covered with potentially useful striking surfaces, making it an incredibly adaptable potential living weapon.
Does having so many choices, however, really benefit the user? I suppose it depends.
I recently overheard a veteran martial artist explain to a novice the difference in the side kick using the heel versus the knife foot. He went on to explain that the main difference is in the type of damage caused. The heel kick is more “crushing” whereas the outer edge of the foot is more “cutting”. Giving numerous examples, he also showed how the knife foot allows for more surgical precision reaching smaller targets like the throat or individual ribs.
As I listened, memories of my childhood training in Tang Soo Do came to mind. It seems that this explanation is pretty standard in traditional martial arts. It also seems to be common to teach proper knife foot positioning by practicing walking on the edges of one’s feet.
In my own classes, however, I never teach the side kick utilizing the knife foot. The structure of the foot and ankle simply does not allow safe execution of a strike with the foot in a supinated position. The foot and ankle are essentially a very complex support system designed for strength, mobility, shock absorption and stability just to name a few. Extending the the delicate foot muscles, tendons, and ligaments to the end of their range of motion, as in pronation or suponation, weakens the foot and increases the likelihood of a sprain.
In my acupuncture practice, I have treated numerous ankle sprains with over ninety percent of those coming from foot supination, much like the knife foot position except that the ankle was pushed just a tiny bit further than it wanted to go.
Kicking with the heel, on the other hand, places the shock of striking on the strongest part of the foot; the part designed to withstand high impact.
Admittedly, the knife foot side kick does look nice . . . which is probably why Bruce Lee is seen utilizing it for the camera.
Just remember, that the knife foot looks nice in the movies, but it is about as effective for kicking as it is for running.
Keep it simple and just use your heel.

Happy Training!
–
Nhan-Esteban Khuong, L.Ac.
www.SGVJeetKuneDo.com